SH4 ATO Roll Call

[pdiddy]

It's pretty quiet in this forum. Anybody playing SH4 on the German side?

[steevo45]

Playing OM cruising off Ireland mid 1940 at the moment.....

[ReallyDedPoet]

Have not in quite a while, but will again :yep:

[jldjs]

Yep, started about a month ago with OpMonsun and Omegu. Got tired of TMO.
But, sure do miss the PK. My first impressions;
Allied airplanes are deadly, a UBoat without detecting radar is dead meat
Determining speed much more difficult than it was on Pacific mods
Allied escorts seem to find me much easier than Pacific mods
Harder to get hits using UBoat's TDC, especially if you're "on the move", and ranges beyond 5k meters.
But, it is challenging and renewed by desire to play since I fell into boredom on the Pacific side.

[Sailor Steve]

Since my gaming was curtailed for several years I've been out of the loop. First I'll be running three careers side-by-side in SH3, one from each available base, starting in August. After I'm into September I'll be adding SH4, and maybe have some fun with Aces again. I'll be going through the war month by month, adding more games as the dates come up. :sunny:

[raymond6751]

I'm on a world cruise, just for the heck of it. Long, long voyage.

[Hitman]

Not been at (vritual) sea for long, but I am never far from these forums. Some day it will hook me again and I will be back to sea with SH3 and SH4 / OM because nothing has come out after those games that seems better. Some day.

Good hunting :salute:

[Threadfin]

Not at the moment. Recently I played a career in OM which was detailed here

http://www.subsim.com/radioroom/showthread.php?t=215991

Not that anyone noticed, or commented anyway lol

But it's a great mod and I really enjoyed it. First time back in German boats since my SH3 days.

The KiUB is just excellent, my favorite attack periscope screen in any subsim or mod.

jldjs -- Do you use a nomograph? It's essential to be using map contacts really, and if you are, the nomgraph will make it quick and easy to determine a speed. Make a mark on the target's location. Wait a few minutes, I usually used a 3 minute interval. Then mark again. Use the compass to measure the distance travelled and then use the ruler on the nomograph to determine speed. My apologies if you already know this.

[jldjs]

Thx Threadfin but I know how to use map, contacts on, and I use 3 min
15 sec for interval to get Kms. The difficulty is with determining
speed in the midst of attacking a convoy. No time
to plot! With PK on US subs you could guess and check
on the attack map. Can't do that on U boats! But, does make
it more challenging to attack and evade!

[steevo45]

Actually, I really loved your account of your adventures in U47, just so you know. Good hunting

[Threadfin]

Thanks mate. Appreciate it.


jldjs -- Yes, I thought you would probably know what to do, kindly disregard the advice. FWIW, the vast majority of convoys I contacted during that career were making 6 knots, but of course not all were.

[jldjs]

On the convoy speed I too concluded 5-6kts was best guess. It's those pesky escorts! I just can't stop tryin' to hit them! I'm still trying to get closer to TFs and convoys.
BTW, enjoyed your posts re U-47.

[Threadfin]

Thanks very much. As I mentioned in those reports I found that sea state was key for me getting in on convoys and task forces. There were only a few instances where I got in when the sea was calm, during both submerged and surfaced attacks.

[les green01]

hadn't play in a while but getting ready to fire up again with a sick family member and with her passing on have a week off of work

[podunkpete]

I'm into March '43, and just had an INCREDIBLE run in with a large convoy in AM71. Ships everywhere including the first T3's I've seen. Don't you know I've got to take out escorts! Saving the game (thinking I'll be dead soon) I throw caution to the wind and go crazy. 7 escorts go down with one fish each. It almost seemed they only wanted to go to the sinking ships, rather than come after me. Enough of them remained to nearly sink me; I've got three dead, many wounded, but I am underway on the surface and headed for France.:o

[bsachems]

Hello Captains,
I just got o new rig and went to install sh4 v1.5 and the cd code didn't work. Still waiting for help from UPlay. I have been playing the pacific mods for years. They never get old.
Thank You to the Creators.

[ReallyDedPoet]

Welcome back to SUBSIM :sunny:

Hopefully you get your issue sorted.

[CaptBones]

...playing U-Boat Atlantic campaigns in SH4/OM and SH3/GWX3, as well as U.S. Pacific campaign in SH4/TMO...and waiting anxiously for LSH3_v6!

Gave SH5 a try, but even with the wonderful fixes and improvements by a very dedicated and talented modding community, it was still too much of an "arcade" style game (score the required points and move up to the next level...blah blah blah).

The dynamic campaigns in SH3 and 4 still seem to be the best at simulation of the submarine campaigns of WWII (even allowing for the near-terminal boredom occasionally experienced with TMO/RSRD :arrgh!:).

I just wish Ubi, or anyone, would take the best features of all three of the latter SH series and make a "definitive" sub simulation to cover the entire spectrum from WWI through the end of the "Cold War". But, I also wish for 'world peace' and the end to hunger, disease and suffering...seems it just ain't gonna' happen.