Log in

View Full Version : History/Realism Question.


Paulie76
11-14-10, 02:15 PM
In the wider area of the channel, with 37 meters under keel. Blue the speed estimate on a Tramp steamer and ended up hitting her on the forward hull rather than beneath the engine.

Cursed myself, surfaced with the intent to finish her off with the deck gun, only to told by my sissy watch officer that the seas were too rough. Moot point though since I could see her starting to list...she was going down, but she was taking a long time to do it.

http://i136.photobucket.com/albums/q180/Paulie76_album/General%20Pics/patrol1.jpg

http://i136.photobucket.com/albums/q180/Paulie76_album/General%20Pics/patrol2.jpg

Watching her go down, I strayed too close and in her last dying moments she had the audacity to turn her search beams on me! Picked me out dead to rights. She had more than enough time before going down to radio my position, so now how much trouble am I in?

http://i136.photobucket.com/albums/q180/Paulie76_album/General%20Pics/map.jpg

Is the AI smart enough (and realistic enough) to send out ships from Portsmouth and Cherbourg to intercept me? Or am I pretty safe? Suffice it to say I'm pretty dang paranoid at the moment.

Jimbuna
11-14-10, 02:24 PM
The game engine will throw an imaginary dice and decide if the radio message was received successfully, what assets are within range of you etc.

Madox58
11-14-10, 03:47 PM
Your in the Channel!
:o
What year?

What's the first rule about the Channel?

Paulie76
11-14-10, 04:04 PM
Your in the Channel!
:o
What year?

What's the first rule about the Channel?

Uh...never attack ships in the channel? :)

It's early in the War, though. October 7th, 1939. So I'm hoping I got a bit of breathing room before they really get their act together.

Jimbuna
11-14-10, 04:07 PM
Your in the Channel!
:o
What year?

What's the first rule about the Channel?

Uh...never attack ships in the channel? :)

It's early in the War, though. October 7th, 1939. So I'm hoping I got a bit of breathing room before they really get their act together.

STAY OUT OF THE CHANNEL!! http://www.psionguild.org/forums/images/smilies/wolfsmilies/pirate.gif

Yoriyn
11-14-10, 04:25 PM
Heh.. I read somewhere on subsim forum in Silent Hunter 5 section about guy who finish SH5 campaign with score about 3,500,000 tons. Thats realistic :D

Madox58
11-14-10, 04:26 PM
desirableroasted put it best.

"Stay out of the Channel, unless ordered there. If you simply must use it, because of low fuel, for example, think of it as dark, thug-filled alley in a strange city and act accordingly. If you just glance at someone wrong in the Channel, you will attract more trouble than you can ever deal with."

:har:

Capt. Morgan
11-14-10, 04:30 PM
IIRC, if the game decides to send enemies your way, it will send anything that is within 30 minutes of your location. For destroyers, that's about 15 nautical miles away. For aircraft it's a lot more.

Fortunately Portsmouth and Cherbourg are too far away, but you should expect company. Good thing the weather is bad, the planes will have a hard time spotting you.

You can hear farther than you can see, so I would suggest leaving at full speed on the surface, with frequent hydrophone checks to keep clear of any contacts... and heed the words of desirableroasted as quoted above.

With a little luck, you'll survive.

Madox58
11-14-10, 05:08 PM
If you have the fuel?
Head for the Atlantic to go home.
You won't like the Straits!

Rhodes
11-14-10, 06:32 PM
I prefer face a firing squad that go to channel, even if ordered...

Sailor Steve
11-14-10, 07:19 PM
Why was the speed estimate blue? Isn't red better?

K-61
11-14-10, 07:23 PM
Why was the speed estimate blue? Isn't red better?

Ewe beet me too it. :D

Paulie76
11-14-10, 07:35 PM
Why was the speed estimate blue? Isn't red better?

Hahaha! took me a couple of seconds to realize what the heck you were referring too. Normally my spelling is a lot better. I swear!

Sailor Steve
11-14-10, 07:48 PM
I swear sometimes too, but that's another story.

I must agree with the others. The only time I ever go through The Channel is when I start a career in August 1939. It's a leisurely trip out, and I take the long way around coming home, and every time after that. Even with the nastiest mods it's still easier than it was in real life, but it's really not worth it. It's called the English Channel for a reason.

Missing Name
11-14-10, 08:08 PM
I flat-out refuse to go any further into the Channel than an imaginary line drawn directly north from Brest. And that is REALLY pushing it.

Gargamel
11-14-10, 08:41 PM
I flat-out refuse to go any further into the Channel than an imaginary line drawn directly north from Brest. And that is REALLY pushing it.

If I can, I try to stay off the continental shelf altogether. I've learned my lesson.

desirableroasted
11-15-10, 05:48 AM
In the wider area of the channel, with 37 meters under keel. Blue the speed estimate on a Tramp steamer and ended up hitting her on the forward hull rather than beneath the engine.

Actually, in rough seas, a shot forward usually brings them down quicker than a shot amidships.

desirableroasted
11-15-10, 08:09 PM
desirableroasted put it best.

"Stay out of the Channel, unless ordered there. If you simply must use it, because of low fuel, for example, think of it as dark, thug-filled alley in a strange city and act accordingly. If you just glance at someone wrong in the Channel, you will attract more trouble than you can ever deal with."

:har:


Thanks for the quote. Where was my editorial sense?

"The Channel? It's a cesspool of thugs and cutpurses. It's a dark alley of skulking miscreants whose only advantage is their number and their weapons. Let one look at you... and every one will jump you."

Pithier?

ralphnader23
11-15-10, 10:44 PM
I know when I was first playing stock, before I switched to GWX, it seemed like they would send a destroyer or a plane almost anytime I sunk a ship fairly close to England. However in GWX I've seen less interceptors come searching in the area after a sinking.