Sonar

[pickinthebanjo]

As I advance in my career I usually like to pick up the best sonar I can. When I catch ships that are unescorted I start pinging them until I have an exact range.
My question is this, can merchants hear the ping like a naval vessel can? I've never noticed that they could but it has been a while since I made it that far into a career to have sonar. Also how well does that sonar that gives range/speed work? I think it is one one the later models.

[Jimbuna]

Next time your near an escort start pinging like mad....then post your findings :DL

Play the gramaphone loud and take repeated depth soundings whilst your at it :03:

[timmy41]

if you can audibly hear the sonar, they should be able too. later in the war sonar was developed that was not audible to the human ear (just a side effect of the development, that was not the exact objective) but would still cause the ship and things to rattle, so one could tell when they were being pinged.
im just guessing that non navel ships are not coded to respond to pings.

[maillemaker]

Play the gramaphone loud and take repeated depth soundings whilst your at it

I thought someone had posted that the depth finder does not actually affect your detection profile?

Steve

[Jimbuna]

I thought someone had posted that the depth finder does not actually affect your detection profile?

Steve

That's right/correct it doesn't but neither does much else :DL

[gazpode_l]

never actually had chance to use sonar, not even in a single mission - how wld u turn it on and how wld u go about using such a device?

Is it used in the same way as the hydrophones and I presume it replaces the hydrophones?

[Snestorm]

In game, I don't think the merchants can hear you ping.

In real life, anyone below the waterline can hear it, without any equipment.
I've layed in my rack and heard it many times.
(You can't miss it!)

[MarinS]

never actually had chance to use sonar, not even in a single mission - how wld u turn it on and how wld u go about using such a device?

Is it used in the same way as the hydrophones and I presume it replaces the hydrophones?

No, they can't replace hydrophones because with sonar you can (with help of sound) only determine the distance of target. Sonar can only supplement the hydrophone (now you can, not only detect screw sound, you can even determine their distance ---- small help for attack scope:up:)
How you turn it on????.... I'm manage to do it in only one way. By myself.
Press H to go in sonar station. Turn phone's wheel around and when you found direction of screw sound press SEND(E) button (by your left side). Then you'll hear PING sound. After that go to the periscope and ask your sonarman for distance. He'll give a number;)

[JMV]

Newbies are learning quick those days....

[pickinthebanjo]

In theory a person could torpedo a ships using only the Hydros and sonar. As the hydros would give bearing (and a very innacurate AOB) the Sonar would give Range/Speed (Providing it is the Better sonar)

I guess if I did my calculations/observations correctly it would give me AOB and Speed then afew pings and I'd have range.:hmmm: I'll have to try that

[Weiss Pinguin]

It becomes even easier if you're carrying homing torpedoes. Just work out a basic solution point the torpedo on its way. :arrgh!:

[brazuca22]

No, they can't replace hydrophones because with sonar you can (with help of sound) only determine the distance of target. Sonar can only supplement the hydrophone (now you can, not only detect screw sound, you can even determine their distance ---- small help for attack scope:up:)
How you turn it on????.... I'm manage to do it in only one way. By myself.
Press H to go in sonar station. Turn phone's wheel around and when you found direction of screw sound press SEND(E) button (by your left side). Then you'll hear PING sound. After that go to the periscope and ask your sonarman for distance. He'll give a number;)MarinS, we can get "precise range to target" by just clicking on the radio man, then the sonar icon and ask for precise range. (but this only works if we can see the target on periscope or uzo).

It happens my hydrophone has no buton below "SENDE". The mouse cursor turns red and the word "ping" appears but I can't click anything to ping a contact since no button is present. What can that be?:hmmm:

[Sailor Steve]

In theory a person could torpedo a ships using only the Hydros and sonar. As the hydros would give bearing (and a very innacurate AOB) the Sonar would give Range/Speed (Providing it is the Better sonar)

I guess if I did my calculations/observations correctly it would give me AOB and Speed then afew pings and I'd have range.:hmmm: I'll have to try that
In real life that was the American SOP when they entered the war. It never worked once.