Log in

View Full Version : Planes dropping torps


Armistead
03-24-10, 11:03 AM
They make great runs in single player, one actually sunk my sub...why not available in campaign? I think they're in FORS..correct or not..

tater
03-24-10, 11:09 AM
To what end?

One, in RL subs were not torpedoed by aircraft that I know of.

Two, ASW patrol aircraft would not carry torpedoes, and jap snooper planes also did not carry torpedoes. As a result, the only torpedo-armed planes would be strike forces en route to targets. Even if they saw a sub, they'd ignore it, they'd be OTW to attack a carrier or something better (and in game, they'd attack YOU, which is silly).

keltos01
03-24-10, 11:17 AM
US avenger aircrafts sank I-52 with mk 24 FIDO homing torpedoes

IJN had MAD equipped planes that would drop DC I think

keltos

tater
03-24-10, 11:37 AM
Yeah, a homing torpedo is a different story, clearly.

Many IJN patrol aircraft carried DCs, not only the MAD equipped units.

SH really falls down on ASW doctrine generally, frankly.

The IJN used dye markers, then had plane try and stay within a radius to hold the boat down. MAD aircraft we not typically used to press attacks I think, but to mark the target. I'd be willing to bet other than immediately after diving, few air-dropped DCs ever did any harm whatsoever. It;s all about holding the boat down...