Log in

View Full Version : Any Railroad Tycoon / S.M. 'Railroads' players out there?


SteamWake
08-27-09, 11:57 AM
Im a big fan of the Railroad Tycoon series, I specifically like RRT3 and still play it to this day even though its nearly 6 years old.

Recently I downloaded the demo for "Sid Miers Railroads" which was touted as the latest installment of the series and had a few questions for anyone whom has the full version of Railroads.

I actually bought the full release version of Railroads some time ago and lost it but there was a few things that really turned me off from it. I was wondering if any of these had been addressed in the full version.

1.) Zoom scale, in the original release as in the demo you could only zoom out/in only so far and could not see large portions of the map. Has this been addressed?

2.) Sense of scale. I just got the feeling that two citys were 20 feet from one another instead of 20 miles. I doubt anything has been done about this but it was just an impression.

3.) Simple economic model (as compared to RRT3). Still the same?

4.) Frequent hang ups, loss of performance, and ctd's near endgame when alot of track / trains have been placed.

5.) AI crossing stalemates. Even though you double / triple tracks, provide cross overs etc. The AI does not do well on choosing routes and often end up at a red light stale mate that takes several minutes to resolve. The demo did seem a little better about this or I got better at laying track but I remeber it being at times a game stopper.

Just wondering the retail game is only 19 bucks but Id like to know before I spring for it. The last time I got it I quickly lost interest and went back to RRT3.

Task Force
08-27-09, 12:15 PM
I have RRT 2 and 3... I got rrt2 when I got my first computer in I think... 1997-8... fun game...

Oberon
08-27-09, 01:01 PM
Haven't really been able to get into the series since the original.
Big Transport Tycoon fan though :rock:

Task Force
08-27-09, 01:02 PM
Haven't really been able to get into the series since the original.
Big Transport Tycoon fan though :rock:

Ive got that game also. lol

Biggles
08-27-09, 01:47 PM
RRT3 is 6 years old?!:o

SteamWake
08-27-09, 02:26 PM
Sid Meier's Railroad Tycoon is a business simulation game.
There are five versions; the original Railroad Tycoon (1990), Railroad Tycoon Deluxe (1993), Railroad Tycoon II (1998), Railroad Tycoon 3 (2003), and Sid Meier's Railroads (2006).

Yea I know hell Railroads is three years old. :o

Whats even more shocking is the original is almost 20 years old !

Task Force
08-27-09, 02:30 PM
and rrt 2 is 10... Aaaahhh... me first computer and busness game... (rrt2 was me first Computer game.):yep:

HunterICX
08-27-09, 03:28 PM
Haven't really been able to get into the series since the original.
Big Transport Tycoon fan though :rock:

:rock:Ow Yes Transport Tycoon....wasted hours on that game :D
It's fun in the locomotive and Diesel age

HunterICX

AngusJS
08-27-09, 04:21 PM
I loved RRT2 and played it to death. I could never get into RRT3 because of one thing: the game's insistence that cargo be sold off at the next scheduled stop. In RRT2 I loved setting up trains that handled only one type of freight, loading up at several freight stations and then hauling it to a manufacturing station. But instead of allowing me to hold onto the freight and sell it where I could get the best price, RRT3 would sell it at the next station, where it was worth nothing.

Are there any mods for RRT3?

Oberon
08-27-09, 04:26 PM
You might want to look over here Hunter, if you haven't already:

http://www.tt-forums.net/

But yes, RRT and TT are massive time-sinks. Locomotion is fun too, better graphics and sound, but it hasn't got quite the following that TT has.

Sailor Steve
08-29-09, 03:17 PM
I have RRT 1 and 2. I've played 1, but get bored after awhile. Not that I think it's boring; I've just discovered that I'm not very good at financial planning and business management.

Spike88
08-29-09, 03:53 PM
I would have Railroads but it doesn't work on Vista. Which is weird because the demo does. :nope:

I've played 2 in gametap, and 3 doesn't work with vista either I believe.

Shearwater
09-01-09, 07:08 PM
RRT3 once caused my system to crash :o I mean not only ctd, but I had to set up the whole darn machine all over again ... With the patch though, it never happened again.
I've read somewhere that the 'new' (or not so new) RR-game by Sid Meyer has a more 'toy-like' look and feel to it. That has always been kind of a put down to try the game myself.

Otto_Weddigen
09-06-09, 12:11 AM
I'm a Railroad Tycoon fan but only trains I love in that game is the pacific type

Shaffer4
10-15-09, 03:19 PM
I have RRT3 and I miss Transport Tycoon, I still have it but have never been able to get it running in a non DOS based OS...

NeonSamurai
10-15-09, 04:01 PM
Surprised none of you have mentioned Open TTD http://www.openttd.org/en/ which takes Transport Tycoon Deluxe and makes it even better in a lot of ways (incorporates a lot of the previous hacks and other stuff too that were for TTD).

You do need the original data files from TTD though to use OpenTTD

Locomotion was not very well received by the fan base mainly as it didn't improve much on TTD, and ignored all the fan made progress to it (including the most basic essential stuff such as presignaling and the like)


As for Railroads I am not aware of any major fan mods that fixed the issues. I don't think the devs fixed much (dig up the patch logs though). I never could get into that series myself