...medic ¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡

[Fenixs]

what is the difference between having medical crew and have not doctors?


my crew die too

.thx.

[Hondo314]

My understanding is that if you have injured crew members (not dead ones), and you put them in the same quarters as an officer or PO with a medic qualification, then the injured crew member may get healed up and return to duty before the end of the patrol. Previous discussions have included speculation about whether the presence of a medic accelerates the rate at which fatigued personnel recover. However, I don't recall anyone being able to definitively demonstrate any impact of medics on fatigue recovery.

[Thomen]

My understanding is that if you have injured crew members (not dead ones), and you put them in the same quarters as an officer or PO with a medic qualification, then the injured crew member may get healed up and return to duty before the end of the patrol. Previous discussions have included speculation about whether the presence of a medic accelerates the rate at which fatigued personnel recover. However, I don't recall anyone being able to definitively demonstrate any impact of medics on fatigue recovery. Never had any wounded/injured crew members... only healthy or dead ones. :hmmm:

[Fenixs]

Never had any wounded/injured crew members... only healthy or dead ones. :hmmm:

...i never too... then medical qualification why?

[goggles]

same problem here

i never have wounded only dead:nope:

[RoaldLarsen]

same problem here

i never have wounded only dead:nope:
Different problem here. I have had wounded crew. I have had medics. Never both at the same time.

[irish1958]

Currently working on a mod to remedy the medic problem. In my testing, contrary to what the SHIII manual states, the medic has no effect on fatigue or morale, only injury.

[gadflyjs]

I heard that if the medic heal the wounded one before the end of the patrol, the poor guy won't get the wounded medal. I had this situation once, but not sure/remembered, and then I never put the wounded guy in the same compartment with the medic again:rotfl:

[goggles]

My understanding is that if you have injured crew members (not dead ones), and you put them in the same quarters as an officer or PO with a medic qualification, then the injured crew member may get healed up and return to duty before the end of the patrol. Previous discussions have included speculation about whether the presence of a medic accelerates the rate at which fatigued personnel recover. However, I don't recall anyone being able to definitively demonstrate any impact of medics on fatigue recovery.

really? i could swear that my crew recovers endurance with a medic in the compartment

eh... maby im just crazy:woot:

[irish1958]

I heard that if the medic heal the wounded one before the end of the patrol, the poor guy won't get the wounded medal. I had this situation once, but not sure/remembered, and then I never put the wounded guy in the same compartment with the medic again:rotfl:
That is true; however, you can use CMDR to do this.

[={FH}=Paddy]

@ goggles: Phew, I thought I was the only one to think that too! Maybe I have been expecting it and have conditioned myself to believe that it does in fact happen!! :-?

(Twilight Zone Music.............:rotfl:)

[Lt.Fillipidis]

Is it only me who accidentally tested this? :haha:
I rarelly submerge when i see tommies in flying machines so my flak gunners' survavibility is 2-3 patrols the most. So, yes. When you have medics with you, the wounded bootsmen will heal faster. And if the qualified man is an officer, then you can be sure that your bootman will be patched up and ready for the next encounter. :salute:

[irish1958]

That's true; Depending upon the mod you use with SHIII, healing can be very fast. This can easily be make more realistic, however.

[Hondo314]

My understanding is that if you have injured crew members (not dead ones), and you put them in the same quarters as an officer or PO with a medic qualification, then the injured crew member may get healed up and return to duty before the end of the patrol. Previous discussions have included speculation about whether the presence of a medic accelerates the rate at which fatigued personnel recover. However, I don't recall anyone being able to definitively demonstrate any impact of medics on fatigue recovery.

really? i could swear that my crew recovers endurance with a medic in the compartment

eh... maby im just crazy:woot:

Yes, the crew member will recover his endurance with a medic in the quarters, but the medic doesn't make the recovery FASTER than it would be otherwise. There is a difference between recovering endurance and recovering from wounds.

[Torvald Von Mansee]

So, is there any point in giving an officer the medic qualification? And if both he and a NCO medic are in the same compartment, do they stack?

[irish1958]

So, is there any point in giving an officer the medic qualification? And if both he and a NCO medic are in the same compartment, do they stack?
In the only test I did on this, there was no difference. However, I only tested it once. Also, again with very limited testing, I could see no difference between the officer having the qualification and the NCO. If the NCO had more than one qualification, it appeared that only the first one worked.
Again, I have done only very limited testing on this question.

[Torvald Von Mansee]

In the only test I did on this, there was no difference. However, I only tested it once. Also, again with very limited testing, I could see no difference between the officer having the qualification and the NCO. If the NCO had more than one qualification, it appeared that only the first one worked.
Again, I have done only very limited testing on this question.

Okily dokily!! tyvm

[JHuschke]

Yes, I wouldn't put them in the same compartment with a medic unless they were extremely wounded otherwise they will recieve the Wounded Badge, in most cases I haven't had any wounded or dead on the U-93. :ping: They will never get me!

[Uncle Goose]

In real life there was a medic on board but this was no doctor, more a male nurse. He could take care of small wounds, set broken bones and the like but he could not perform surgery (like when one was hit by shrapnel or bullets). I have noticed that if crew-members get wounded that they sometimes heal and other times don't heal when put together with a medic. It seems to depend how badly wounded they are.

[Melonfish]

my flak gunner earned the wound badge along with his Iron cross for shooting down a twin engined jobbie that was attacking us, he took a round in the process and he made it back alive.
he's back onboard now gunning away happily on his zweiling.

[maxextz]

i had 2 men injured and i think the medic fixed them:D they had a red glow about them;) but after a while they were fine.
the fatigue is a big issue with my lot especially in critical situations they wont do anything:down:

max on u48 patrol 10.

[Von Talon]

I have wounded fellows all the time. My watchmen, deck and flakgunners get always injured. I have crazy style to surface in the middle of enemy destroyers. :rotfl: But more likely they get killed right away. :yeah:
I have 2 medics usually onboard.

[Jimbuna]

IMHO the advantage of having a medic or a PO aboard with the qualification ingame is negligible....I prefer to have an additional torpedo or engineer guy.

[irish1958]

That's right; the medic is an unfinished portion of the game, never really implemented.

[Snestorm]

My Flak Gunners and Medic have a great deal in common.
I keep both on board, and have never had to use either.
A L A R M ! ! !

[FIREWALL]

Give me a good deadeye Gunner PO over a lame medic any day.

The other side will need the medics. :p2:

[irish1958]

Give me a good deadeye Gunner PO over a lame medic any day.

The other side will need the medics. :p2:

Patton: "The purpose of war in not to die for your country, but to make the other poor bastard die for his."