Active sonar Pinging in the hunt for the Red October and DW

[Castout]

The difference between the pinging in the movie and DW or SC is so wide.

In DW you hear a high pitch sound while in the Hunt for the Red October you get a bouncing sound of a small stone being thrown off the hull.

Which one is more realistic. The hunt for the Red October imo is a very realistic movie well apart for the hydrodynamic propulsion system :).

I would like to mod the pinging sound to sound more like the hunt for the red october but I have my doubts since I have no knowledge whatsoever on how an active pinging sound like in RL.

Any clue? I'll share the sound which I took from SH3 mod if you want it or provide you with the link.

I mean the name is active PINGING and not active HISSING.

I remember a thread back then when everyone seemed not to like the default SC pinging sound effect.

Anyone can tell me which one is more realistic?

[To be]

The hunt for the Red October imo is a very realistic movie

Like when they detonate the helo dropped torp with a remote control? :hmm:

[Bubblehead Nuke]

REAL active sonar is cool as heck sounding. It is a shame that I can not give you a good example.

Might as well stay with the DW sound. It works and most people know what it means.

Maybe I can give you an example:

http://www.freesound.org/samplesViewSingle.php?id=31038

[Castout]

The hunt for the Red October imo is a very realistic movie
Like when they detonate the helo dropped torp with a remote control? :hmm:

That too I was too lazy to type them.

[Castout]

REAL active sonar is cool as heck sounding. It is a shame that I can not give you a good example.

Might as well stay with the DW sound. It works and most people know what it means.

Maybe I can give you an example:

http://www.freesound.org/samplesViewSingle.php?id=31038

I'll check it out. Though downloading it needs me to be registered