PDA

View Full Version : Should I be able to get away with this?


Quagmire
05-22-07, 02:48 PM
I have found a 100% reliable convoy attack method that is a sure fire winner. Sneak into a convoy and fire off your first salvo. Once detected (I am using Trigger Maru so I am always detected) go to ahead flank at periscope depth.

Leave your periscope up so that the destoryers always know where you are. Crazy you say? Not really.

When a DD begins its attack run order hard to port/starboard so that you can turn inside his turning circle. This will put you into a position where he is crossing your T on his attack run.

Now here is the best part. The DD will slide nicely over your stern just aft of your conning tower (you can get up close and personal with the DD deckhands through your scope at this point) and begin dropping charges. The best part is that the charges never explode shallow enough to do any damage. And since you were at flank speed you are out of the way of the side throwers before they do any damage.


Now if you really want to "Be More Aggressive!" you can do this. As soon as his last charge goes off order full back emergency. Since the DD will always circle around for another run this puts him directly in front of you. All you need to do then is:

1) Turn off the PK
2) Lock the DD on your scope
3) Set the speed on the TDC to 0
4) Set the spread of a torp to 20 deg left or right (depending on the direction of travel of the DD). This allows you to lead the target.
5) When he hits 0 deg bearing quickly update the AOB to 90 deg (important!) and then quickly fire! (Dont forget to open the tube door first!)

You will hit the DD 8 out of 10 times. :arrgh!:

Now, is this historically legit or am I exploiting the weak AI or bugged DM? You just cant get killed at peri depth if you can maneuver.

wetwarev7
05-22-07, 02:53 PM
I'm no expert, but I would think that the destroyers would fire thier main guns at you if they could see your periscope.

Nice trick though! :up:

Quagmire
05-22-07, 02:54 PM
Oh sure they fire their guns at you. But they rarely hit, especially at night! :rotfl:

Quillan
05-22-07, 03:01 PM
I have found a 100% reliable convoy attack method that is a sure fire winner.
Oh sure they fire their guns at you. But they rarely hit, especially at night! :rotfl:

If they hit at all, then this isn't a sure-fire winner, is it?

MaxT.dk
05-22-07, 03:01 PM
Now, is this historically legit or am I exploiting the weak AI or bugged DM? You just cant get killed at peri depth if you can maneuver.
I'm 200% sure it's not historically legit as no captain in his mind will do such thing, but hey! you're talking to a man who managed to sink over 900k tons in 1 patrol (http://www.subsim.com/radioroom/showpost.php?p=538589&postcount=11), so it sounds fun to me! :rotfl::arrgh!:

Quagmire
05-22-07, 03:13 PM
I have found a 100% reliable convoy attack method that is a sure fire winner. Oh sure they fire their guns at you. But they rarely hit, especially at night! :rotfl:
If they hit at all, then this isn't a sure-fire winner, is it?
I have done this several times and only ONE time they hit. Furthermore, no damage was registered. All they do is make nice little water spouts around my scope!

wetwarev7
05-22-07, 03:19 PM
I have found a 100% reliable convoy attack method that is a sure fire winner. Oh sure they fire their guns at you. But they rarely hit, especially at night! :rotfl:
If they hit at all, then this isn't a sure-fire winner, is it?
I have done this several times and only ONE time they hit. Furthermore, no damage was registered. All they do is make nice little water spouts around my scope!

But you did ask if this was historically legit. historically, you would be very afraid of destroyers shooting at your tin can. :p

MaxT.dk
05-22-07, 03:24 PM
http://www.metacafe.com/watch/305344/destroyer_vs_sub/ <-- That's Quagmire in action! :rotfl:

Quagmire
05-22-07, 04:26 PM
:eek:

I love a good "under the keel" shot! NICE!

Yes that is what I am proposing here. It works most of the time (if not all of the time). I guess SHIV need a HUGE realism patch!

GO MODDERS GO!

Kruger
05-23-07, 05:29 AM
Dunno what else to say... I keep keeping myself from going back to sh3...but I will soon.

StandingCow
05-23-07, 06:08 AM
A few of us... including myself just surface and outgun them.. lol. ;)

Lagger123987
05-23-07, 04:32 PM
A few of us... including myself just surface and outgun them.. lol. ;)

Another casual gamer, jeez, realism addicts are better than casual gamers.

Sailor Steve
05-23-07, 04:35 PM
A few of us... including myself just surface and outgun them.. lol. ;)

Another casual gamer, jeez, realism addicts are better than casual gamers.
No, we just like to think we are.:sunny:

MaxT.dk
05-23-07, 04:55 PM
A few of us... including myself just surface and outgun them.. lol. ;)
Another casual gamer, jeez, realism addicts are better than casual gamers.
Says who? Way to proove it? What does make you think you're better than anyone else? Huh? There's always someone out there better, more knowledgaable and smarter than you, remember it... People with your attitude makes me wanna puke :stare: :dead: :down:

John Channing
05-23-07, 05:18 PM
Temper temper everyone.

It is a game, meant to be enjoyed. No one is better or worse because of the way they decide to enjoy it.

JCC

StandingCow
05-23-07, 07:01 PM
LoL... woah guys, I just did it once I swear... :P

That is by no means how I normally play, it just so happened that if I dared dive... it would be a non stop dive to the bottom. So I decided to gun it out, and took out 2 escorts.