Thinking on a few tank games, advice?

33lima · 09-16-17, 07:03 AM

Each to their own Skybird but I read your original assessment of Steel Fury and thought it a bit on the harsh side. Besides, even though the basic engine is today much as it was after the last patch, SF as it was back then is no basis to judge SF as it is now. It's not as good a tanksim as either SB or SABOW but many find it one of the best.

While I rate SB very highly indeed, especially for its attention to the sort of detail (like crew drills and comms) that other tanksims tend to do less well, IMHO there is no sufficiently compelling reason for anyone who wants a reasonably realistic WW2 experience to consider purchasing a tanksim, however good, that features no WW2 AFVs or units when there are good, dedicated WW2 tanksims available. Which there are.

If you want a good modern (post-WW2) tanksim, buy Steel Beasts or Steel Armor Blaze of War - each has their respective advantages, including price point, # of playable vehicles and so on.

If you want a good WW2 tanksim, buy Steel Fury or Panzer Elite, both preferably.

Lootron · 09-16-17, 12:26 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by 33lima

Each to their own Skybird but I read your original assessment of Steel Fury and thought it a bit on the harsh side. Besides, even though the basic engine is today much as it was after the last patch, SF as it was back then is no basis to judge SF as it is now. It's not as good a tanksim as either SB or SABOW but many find it one of the best.

While I rate SB very highly indeed, especially for its attention to the sort of detail (like crew drills and comms) that other tanksims tend to do less well, IMHO there is no sufficiently compelling reason for anyone who wants a reasonably realistic WW2 experience to consider purchasing a tanksim, however good, that features no WW2 AFVs or units when there are good, dedicated WW2 tanksims available. Which there are.

If you want a good modern (post-WW2) tanksim, buy Steel Beasts or Steel Armor Blaze of War - each has their respective advantages, including price point, # of playable vehicles and so on.

If you want a good WW2 tanksim, buy Steel Fury or Panzer Elite, both preferably.

I plan to get both! The one I think I will enjoy more is the one that has less detail, I'm not looking for a super sim. It will take a while to learn, but I reckon that bot will be very fun!

Also, can you post more of your pics 33ima? They make me drool

33lima · 09-16-17, 12:53 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Lootron

Also, can you post more of your pics 33ima? They make me drool

OK, here we go, Panzer Elite first - pics from some of the missions I'm making for the Britpack '44-x mod, due by the end of the year - it should have vehicles with more 3d tracks and suspensions:

US Shermans in 'sunny Ital-ee' from the PP2-x mod, showing models with 3d suspension:

And the same mod's late-model Panzer IVs, this time in Normandy:

33lima · 09-16-17, 01:05 PM

Now Steel Fury - except the first one; couldn't resist sneaking in an M60 from SABOW:

Now Steel Fury, starting with a couple of scenes from a Jagdtiger mission I made for the 'Schulze's Diary' campaign.

Schulze leads his three Jagdtigers into position covering the bridge he must defend until the Panthers and grenadiers of 2 SS Panzer arrive:

Schulze's gunner lines up the leading platoon of Shermans as they roll towards the bridge:

A scene from the post-battle review, showing US infantry, half-tracks and the Pershings which arrived later, stalled on the western side of the bridge:

Michael Witmann surveys the next bound before advancing up to the N175, north of Villers Bocage:

Later in the battle, Witmann passes a burning enemy carrier as he flanks the stalled British column at Villers Bocage:

Panthers at Prokhorovka:

Stock German campaign:

King Tigers in a winter mission:

In an earlier battle, Schuzle finds himself on Hill 226, up against the Churchills of the Scots Guards:

IS-3 seen through a comrade's gunner's sight

Next three are from 'Do your Job!', a mission in Lockie's campaign based on the movie 'Fury':

Michael Witmann's gunner's view of a Cromwell at Villers Bocage:

Lootron · 09-16-17, 01:23 PM

Thank you! Im about to get panzer elite. I would like to know anythinga bout compatibilty for Windows 10 64-bit. Also, What is the primary sites for mods and the most popular mod?

Panzer Elite on the way!

Aktungbby · 09-16-17, 01:32 PM

Lootron!

Lootron · 09-16-17, 02:07 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Aktungbby

Lootron!

Thanks! Any advice for a complete noob to tank sims and panzer elite?

09-16-17, 01:05 PM	#4
33lima Planesman Join Date: Nov 2002 Location: Belfast, NI Posts: 199 Downloads: 27 Uploads: 0	Now Steel Fury - except the first one; couldn't resist sneaking in an M60 from SABOW: Now Steel Fury, starting with a couple of scenes from a Jagdtiger mission I made for the 'Schulze's Diary' campaign. Schulze leads his three Jagdtigers into position covering the bridge he must defend until the Panthers and grenadiers of 2 SS Panzer arrive: Schulze's gunner lines up the leading platoon of Shermans as they roll towards the bridge: A scene from the post-battle review, showing US infantry, half-tracks and the Pershings which arrived later, stalled on the western side of the bridge: Michael Witmann surveys the next bound before advancing up to the N175, north of Villers Bocage: Later in the battle, Witmann passes a burning enemy carrier as he flanks the stalled British column at Villers Bocage: Panthers at Prokhorovka: Stock German campaign: King Tigers in a winter mission: In an earlier battle, Schuzle finds himself on Hill 226, up against the Churchills of the Scots Guards: IS-3 seen through a comrade's gunner's sight Next three are from 'Do your Job!', a mission in Lockie's campaign based on the movie 'Fury': Michael Witmann's gunner's view of a Cromwell at Villers Bocage: Last edited by 33lima; 09-16-17 at 02:03 PM.

09-16-17, 01:23 PM	#5
Lootron Swabbie Join Date: Sep 2017 Location: USA Posts: 11 Downloads: 0 Uploads: 0	Thanks! Thank you! Im about to get panzer elite. I would like to know anythinga bout compatibilty for Windows 10 64-bit. Also, What is the primary sites for mods and the most popular mod? Panzer Elite on the way! Last edited by Lootron; 09-16-17 at 01:29 PM. Reason: panzer Elite on the way!

09-16-17, 01:32 PM	#6
Aktungbby Gefallen Engel U-666 Join Date: Jul 2013 Location: On a tilted, overheated, overpopulated spinning mudball on Collision course with Andromeda Galaxy Posts: 27,913 Downloads: 22 Uploads: 0	welcome aboard! Lootron! __________________ "Only two things are infinite; The Universe and human squirrelyness; and I'm not too sure about the Universe"

09-16-17, 07:03 AM	#1
33lima Planesman Join Date: Nov 2002 Location: Belfast, NI Posts: 199 Downloads: 27 Uploads: 0	Each to their own Skybird but I read your original assessment of Steel Fury and thought it a bit on the harsh side. Besides, even though the basic engine is today much as it was after the last patch, SF as it was back then is no basis to judge SF as it is now. It's not as good a tanksim as either SB or SABOW but many find it one of the best. While I rate SB very highly indeed, especially for its attention to the sort of detail (like crew drills and comms) that other tanksims tend to do less well, IMHO there is no sufficiently compelling reason for anyone who wants a reasonably realistic WW2 experience to consider purchasing a tanksim, however good, that features no WW2 AFVs or units when there are good, dedicated WW2 tanksims available. Which there are. If you want a good modern (post-WW2) tanksim, buy Steel Beasts or Steel Armor Blaze of War - each has their respective advantages, including price point, # of playable vehicles and so on. If you want a good WW2 tanksim, buy Steel Fury or Panzer Elite, both preferably.