Click here to access the Helosim website
SUBSIM Radio Room Forums

BUYING GAMES, BOOKS, ELECTRONICS, and STUFF
THROUGH THIS LINK SUPPORTS SUBSIM, THANKS!

The Web's #1 BBS for all submarine and naval simulations!

Go Back   SUBSIM Radio Room Forums > General > Helosim.com and Flight Sims

Reply
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
Old 07-15-07, 05:11 AM   #1
AFRIKAKORPS
Helmsman
 
Join Date: Apr 2007
Location: Gilbert, AZ
Posts: 104
Downloads: 9
Uploads: 0
Default Stalling is not my friend

I love Il-2. I've been playing for about a month or two and have become pretty skilled with gunnery and such, I can also pull off quite a few excellent maneuvers to boot. The only real problem I keep running into is stalling. It seems that I stall on almost all my turns, even when I'm careful not to push my plan to hard. The AI seems to be able to do incredible maneuvers and turns around me while I try to keep from stalling. I hate losing kills because of stalling, and its the number one killer to me when playing online.

Since you guys seem like an experienced bunch of professionals I was wondering If you have any tips to improve me turning capabilities.

Thanks!
AFRIKAKORPS is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 07-15-07, 05:41 AM   #2
Skybird
Soaring
 
Skybird's Avatar
 
Join Date: Sep 2001
Location: the mental asylum named Germany
Posts: 40,338
Downloads: 9
Uploads: 0


Default

It strongly depends on the type of aircraft. Some are tame and forgiving, some are neurotic bitches. spend an hour just to qucik-test several different ones, and realise their differendces in turning, then stay with those that you find to match your needs. Mostly, these will be planes that are considered a bit too tame against later war opposition, so do quick missions against comparable - or even the same! - type of planes.

Check these planes in and out. I for example love the Hurricane. It is by far not the strongest beast around, but it allows me to focus on what I want to do: flying. Check the behavior at different speeds. Make mental notes of these. The better you learn to handle a plane, the more you gain the ability to successfully fight in these planes, even against opponents that technically should be superior to your plane. Some of the top German aces sticked to their version/models of the Bf109 throughout the war and refused with determination to fly any of the later, considered stronger models.

Learn to fly aerobatics, especially hammerheads. Hammerheads teqaches you to watch both your flight attitude and speed, and perfect your timing and use of thottle. I even did that with the SF260 in Flight simulator, and later found it easier in the - less sophisticated - flight models in IL2. Train extreme turns, leanr the b ahvior with different throttle use.

finally and most important: fly ina way that matches the strengths of the plane you are in - not it'S weaknesses. The German planes were not turn fighters, but energy fighters: use the vertical, zoom-and-boom. Other planes are low on energy, but strong in turnings: so don't try to outrace that Messerschmidt, but try to lure it into a turnfight, close to the ground.

Planes also behave differently at different altitudes. Some better fight high above, some better at tree level

So, why not trying a Hurricane vs Hurricane duel next for a start?

Finally: tune your input devices, adjust the axis sensitivity. this needs solid testing and can cost a lot of time, but it is worth it.
__________________
If you feel nuts, consult an expert.
Skybird is online   Reply With Quote
Old 07-15-07, 10:07 AM   #3
XabbaRus
Navy Seal
 
Join Date: Sep 2001
Posts: 5,330
Downloads: 5
Uploads: 0


Default

Also with WWII planes you can't just yank the stick especially at high speed.

In order to turn quickly I'll give you an example.

Your at a good speed 400kph or above. Roll into your turn and then start with a gentle pull on the stick. This will start you pulling into the turn. Once it has started pull harder on the stick watching your speed. This way you will able to get a good rate of turn.
__________________
XabbaRus is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 07-15-07, 11:16 AM   #4
NeonSamurai
Ocean Warrior
 
Join Date: Jan 2002
Location: Socialist Republic of Kanadia
Posts: 3,044
Downloads: 17
Uploads: 0


Default

This is very true, and one of the reasons why i cant play prop plane sims currently as the joystick i have right now is very twitchy, which has the anoying habbit of throwing ww1&2 planes into spins, stalls, not to mention makes accurate gunnery impossible. Modern jet fighters i dont have that problem as they are fly by wire and the flight computer eliminates the dangerous twitching (though it still can pitch around alot and gun shots are still very difficult). Fortunatly i should have a new joystick in a month or so.
NeonSamurai is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 07-15-07, 02:52 PM   #5
AFRIKAKORPS
Helmsman
 
Join Date: Apr 2007
Location: Gilbert, AZ
Posts: 104
Downloads: 9
Uploads: 0
Default

Thanks for the reply guys!

Yeah, I like to fly in a lot of different planes, so I never fully learn what they are capable of and what disadvantages are. Usually speed isn't an issue; I'm usually flying at 300 to 350 knots depending on the aircraft. I guess I am going to see what works for me, and I am definitely going to read up on all the aircraft so I can learn what they excel at.

Quote:
Originally Posted by NeonSamurai
This is very true, and one of the reasons why i cant play prop plane sims currently as the joystick i have right now is very twitchy, which has the anoying habbit of throwing ww1&2 planes into spins, stalls, not to mention makes accurate gunnery impossible. Modern jet fighters i dont have that problem as they are fly by wire and the flight computer eliminates the dangerous twitching (though it still can pitch around alot and gun shots are still very difficult). Fortunatly i should have a new joystick in a month or so.
I have the same problem with my X52, it seems WAY to sensitive and it makes gunnery difficult since I cant keep my plane level half the time. I just wish the X52 had more resistance.
AFRIKAKORPS is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 07-16-07, 03:58 PM   #6
NeonSamurai
Ocean Warrior
 
Join Date: Jan 2002
Location: Socialist Republic of Kanadia
Posts: 3,044
Downloads: 17
Uploads: 0


Default

Mine is not so much sensitive as it is plain unreliable, at anything other then full back or centered (with alot of deadbanding) it will twitch around and not hold at a steady rate (sometimes twitching the full range back and forth very rapidly). This makes smooth turns or lining up shots totaly impossible
NeonSamurai is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 07-16-07, 09:30 PM   #7
Chock
Sea Lord
 
Join Date: May 2005
Location: Under a thermal layer in chilly Olde England
Posts: 1,842
Downloads: 0
Uploads: 0
Default

Tips to avoid stalling (and some other stuff):

Flying smoothly will reduce the chances of stalling, but one thing you need to be aware of is that your 'stalling speed' increases massively when you are banked over at a high angle of attack, since most of your lift vector is going into turning your aircraft instead of keeping you in the sky, which effectively increases your wing loading massively. The chance of stalling is also made much more likely by a badly co-ordinated turn in this situation.

A badly co-ordinated turn will block off the airflow to one of your inner wings (because you'll be flying slightly sideways in a badly co-ordinated turn, so the fuselage will be in the way of the airflow). This can cause one wing to stall early. This will cause a spin, as one wing will still be flying while the other one aint, consequently you'll spin in the direction of the stalled wing. This is exactly what is happening when you see a sycamore leaf 'helicoptering' its way to the ground when it falls from a tree (technically it is 'autorotating' rather than 'helicoptering' but anyway..).

Unfortunately in a simulator, you cannot feel the slip of a badly co-ordinated turn like you can in real life, so you have to rely on the turn and slip indicator on your instrument panel to show you when it is happening (at least until you get used to handling the aeroplane anyway), there is a picture of a turn and slip indicator here:

http://www.allstar.fiu.edu/aero/turn...pindicator.htm

The instrument consists of two elements, the upper needle, which indicates the rate of turn, often it will be marked with something like the following: '1 minute and 2 minutes'. The bottom half of the instrument has a small white ball suspended in liquid, this ball indicates how well co-ordinated your turn is (if the ball is in the centre while you are turning, you are flying smoothly and in a well co-ordinated turn. To keep your turn co-ordinated, you apply rudder to keep the ball centred in the middle. The easiest way to do this is to use a technique known as 'treading on the ball', what this means is that in a real aeroplane, if the ball is off-centre in a turn, whichever side it is off towards, that is the rudder pedal you press down on, doing this will centre up the ball (on a pc joystick with a rudder control, you'll have to do this by twisting the stick in that direction instead of giving it a bootful of rudder as you do on the real thing).

The 'minute markings on the turn and slip indicator work like this: If you put your plane in a bank with the needle on the 1 minute mark, it will take you exactly one minute to perform a 360 degree turn. This is known as a 'rate 1 turn', obviously in a bank on the 2 minute mark it would take you 2 mins to make a 360 degree turn. The point of this is so that you can make accurate timed turns purely on instruments, for things like holding patterns and the like. Most of this not being hugely relevant to combat flying.

Remember that you don't turn an aeroplane with the rudder, you turn it by putting some of the wing's lift vector off to one side, and then co-ordinate the turn by using the rudder to kick the tail outwards so that your nose is constantly facing the airflow.

In combat flying the important thing to bear in mind is that fancy flying will not shoot anyone down, but smooth flying will conserve more energy and keep your speed up as well as causing you to lose less height. Either of these is good. Speed can be converted into height by pulling up, height can be converted into speed by diving. And the one with the most energy is usually the one who will win a battle between aeroplanes.

But, bear this in mind too, the real way to use a fighter plane is not to get into a dogfight at all, instead you should only engage when you have an advantage. This might not seem fair, but the truth is that figher pilots are not in the business of being fair, their job is to kill people and shoot down aeroplanes. The best way to do this is to sneak up behind people and shoot them in the ass, preferably from a much greater height, so that you can perform a hit and run attack and then either zoom back up to height, or dive away and run off. Forget all that 'Knights of the Air' chivalry bollocks. You have to be a sneaky nasty b*st*rd.

If you do get into a turning fight, if both you and your opponent have aircraft with similar capabilities, then whoever can turn in the most efficient manner will be the one who wins (always assuming you can hit what you shoot at when firing a deflection shot). So, two things become important here, the first one is instantaneous turn rate, and the second one is sustained turn rate. Instantaneous turn rate being how fast your aeroplane can actually bank into a turn (the FW-190 is probably going to be the best one at this). Nevertheless, sustained turn rate is more important in a prolonged dogfight, and there is not a lot to choose between many of the famous fighter aeroplanes in this respect, although the Hawker Hurricane is one that has a good sustained turn rate.

This means that knowing your favourite aircraft's capabilities, and being able to use them to best advantage is what will win the day. Of course you have a massive advantage over real fighter pilots in some respects, as you can try out what are likely to be your enemy's aircraft and find their strengths and weaknesses too!

What you should do is get into your favourite aircraft and find out its ideal 'corner velocity'. You can do this by turning yourself into a test pilot for a few minutes and doing this:

Load up your favourite fighter plane, and fly it on a mission with no enemies around. Try several turns at various speeds until you determine which one gets your around in a circle the quickest (this is unlikely to be at full throttle, where your high speed will make your radius of turn very large). you can check your rate of turn for various speeds by going into a turn, noting your compass heading, and timing how long it takes you to get around back to the same heading. Try several speeds and also try it at various heights too, say 25,000 feet, 15,000 feet and maybe 5,000 feet. One of these will give you a better rate of turn than the others (for some aircraft it will be high up, others will be good low down). When you know your best height and best speed to turn fastest at that height, you'll know what height to dogfight at.

If you really must dogfight, the two moves above all other to perfect are the 'High Yo-Yo', and the 'Low yo-yo'. In a high yo-yo, you pull up in the turn a little, then kick down on the rudder, effectively this will 'extend the corner' a little, temporarily giving putting you high, the upwards element of the move will put you into a lag pursuit above the enemy aircraft's wing-line, which means it is useful to prevent an overshoot of your target, kicking down of the rudder, or rolling inverted and pulling back hard on the stick will likely give you a chance at a potshot, or you can barrel roll onto the target to get the nose around further. In a Low yo-yo, you kick on bottom rudder and cut the corner of your turn by chnging the vector of travel slightly, this will increase your speed and your turn rate temporarily, and is helpful if you can't quite get your nose around tight enough for a potshot at your enemy, it's important in a low yo-yo to keep positive G on the aircraft, so when you initiate this move, you will probably be inverted for a few seconds if you are doing it right, eventually rolling level and continuing the pursuit with you closer to the bad guy's tail. The low yo-yo is also a good move to try if you want to make a break for it (for example if you are out of ammo or running out of gas - although doing this is always going to be risky). It can be tricky for your enemy to keep you in sight when you do a low yo-yo.

Low yo-yo: http://www.flightsimbooks.com/jfs/page98.php

Note that some aircraft are not good at this kind of turning fight (P-47 Thunderbolt, F4U Corsair for example), in which case you should not try and dogfight with the aircraft at all, instead going for dive and zoom tactics. The way to do this is to turn away from the battle and climb up to a really high altitude, come right over the dogfight and dive down on enemy aircraft fire at them and then use your massive speed picked up in the dive to climb back up again, then repeat the whole thing again.

If you do this properly, you will be practically invulnerable to most 'turn and burn fighters' and if you do this on a public server, you'll end up with lots of people accusing you of hacking, since you'll most likely kick everyone's ass. Try it, it's funny as hell watching people that think they are great fighter pilots getting their asses shot off by you in a plane that they know turns like a truck!

Chock
__________________

Last edited by Chock; 07-16-07 at 09:59 PM.
Chock is offline   Reply With Quote
Reply

Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off

Forum Jump


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 07:47 AM.


Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright © 1995- 2024 Subsim®
"Subsim" is a registered trademark, all rights reserved.