A Gift for sound Modders & Others

[Paul.Saenger]

Originally Posted by Boris

As I see it, any song a U-Boat crew might have listened to is fair game. I'm not for this censorship of songs deemed unappropraite. They're historical relics in my opinion. They certainly won't make me a nazi. Same as me singing along to Toby Keith wont make me an American patriot.

As to whether you listen to them...your choice. However, since my family was almost wiped out due to the war, you'll understand if I do not go along with this. I for one have no problems playing the game, but I will not do so while listening to the praises of a man who is directly responsible for over 50 deaths in my family.

[NealT]

I salute you for having the sensitivity to put this out and ask opinions instead of running the risk of offending seriously some. Not only that, but it sure seems like you are responding quickly and appropriately to the feedback you are getting.

I also have to salute those who have provided 'constructive criticism' and 'positive feedback' in a non-destructive and non-confrontational manner. A true sign of how mature this group of game-players are.

[Philipp_Thomsen]

Jeez, the man is already dead, chill...

Good part of my family (gooooood part) was killed as well, but war is war, this sh!t happens, people have to die, if its not my family, will be my neighboor's family. Past is past, shouldn't hurt. Realism is what matters for me. If in WW2 those sailors really did listen to songs praising Hitler, I dont have a problem listen to it while I'm playing, coz Im doing it for realism, not praising him. He's dead, means nothing nowdays.

All you guys have to chillout about Hitler, he's not coming back.

[Laufen zum Ziel]

I may be wrong but it is my understanding that U-Boot crews smuggled their records aboard. Once at sea they replaced the propaganda music with their own.

Does anyone know if this is correct

There have been a lot of pro & con on what to leave or not leave in regard to the music. My own opinnion is that I will, mostly, lean towards sensitivity.

Jeder hat das Recht auf eine Stellungnahme. Mine ist mir die Hölle vor diesem Boot.

http://silent-hunter-addict.com

[Boris]

Originally Posted by Laufen zum Ziel

I may be wrong but it is my understanding that U-Boot crews smuggled their records aboard. Once at sea they replaced the propaganda music with their own.

Does anyone know if this is correct

There have been a lot of pro & con on what to leave or not leave in regard to the music. My own opinnion is that I will, mostly, lean towards sensitivity.

Jeder hat das Recht auf eine Stellungnahme. Mine ist mir die Hölle vor diesem Boot.

http://silent-hunter-addict.com

I always like to think this was the case... I'm a lenient captain when it comes to contraband

[balto63]

Originally Posted by Laufen zum Ziel

Thanks Dutchie-one,

I checked and the download site has them wrong. I am fairly sure of the German and english ones. http://silent-hunter-addict.com I need somone who speaks Russian, Dutch, Hungarian and Italion to listen to these so I can properly lable them.

The italian version of Lilli Marlene is in English :rotfl::rotfl:

I consider all the song as relic, they should be evalueted in their historical environment.
We study story, economy, art and music but they are all linked togheter.

Just my two euros :rotfl::rotfl:

Sorry for my english writing is very rusty like my u-boot