GWX-vs-NYGM

[codmander]

Eye candy and sound -GWX no doubt but gameplay which is more important by the way NYGM by a mile!

[Mooncatt]

i can only speak for GW i never tried out the other one, from what ive heard though it sounds much harder than GW is this true?

[danlisa]

Have you progressed far into the war with GWX?

I can assure you that GWX is most certainly not just "eye candy & sounds".

Of course you are entitled to your opinion.

[ReallyDedPoet]

Its all personal preference. That is the good thing about this sim, there are many options to suit your style of play.

[MRV]

if you think its realistic sinking a tugboat with 3 torpedoes then go ahead with NYGM

[Mooncatt]

just guessing is GW the same as GWX i havent been around for a while well quite a while so im just catching up at the moment

[stabiz]

Originally Posted by codmander

Eye candy and sound -GWX no doubt but gameplay which is more important by the way NYGM by a mile!

Am I the only one who is abit sick of these statements?

[danlisa]

Originally Posted by stabiz

Am I the only one who is abit sick of these statements?

Nope



@ Mooncatt

GWX is from the same Dev's as GW but it is the equivalent improvement as stock to GW.

Try it out

[Mooncatt]

im gonna thanx i cant believe ive got so far behind, i havent had net access for months. im not sure NYGM would be for me tbh from what ive heard i.e 3 eels to sink a trawler and what-not.

[mookiemookie]

Originally Posted by stabiz

Am I the only one who is abit sick of these statements?

Especially when they have no details to back them up, and GWX has been out for oh....3 days now

Let's not feed the trolls, mmkay?

[Gizzmoe]

Originally Posted by codmander

Eye candy and sound -GWX no doubt but gameplay which is more important by the way NYGM by a mile!

You should have posted a list of things that you think are better in NYGM than in GWX, on that one could base a discussion. To simply write a broad statement is not enough, that looks like trolling.

[codmander]

seems to me in gw/gwx once a convoy is found its a merchant sunk with nygm its far from that which ((in my opion)) is more real but wow!! some fantastic sounds and graphics stuff with gwx i think the 2 modder teams should get together wow think about that!!!

[Pants]

Originally Posted by stabiz

Am I the only one who is abit sick of these statements?

Me too
I am sick of people constaly saying GW is just eye candy...If you have played GWX and come back saying that then you have NOT played GWX propperly
The amount of work put in GWX is mind blowing...I will not say this again GWX IS not only nice one the eyes and ears..but it's so in depth that it will take you at least 2 months of solid playing to find all the changes, and then you may miss some.

[mookiemookie]

It's still ridiculous to be making comparisons when GWX has been out for 3 days. The gameplay changes from TGW that I've seen already are enough to make any comparison obsolete. Basically, you're basing your argument on TGW 1.1a as there's no possible way you could have played GWX long enough to be making any kind of informed judgement.

[codmander]

GWX when scope is on a ship tells what kind of ship on data pad right there i see noobish sighns