Quote:
Originally Posted by Furia
How do you come with this figure of 10 to 20 minutes reload time?
Any source you can share.
For what I have read in several books the reload was far much faster.
Even in Wikipedia they are talking about 3 minutes.
Hedgehog_(weapon) |
it may well be, that's why I used the word "estimate".
I was working from the premise that replacement hedge-hog charges would not be laying around the deck before firing, ready to reload, but would need to be brought up from the magazine. I'd have expected this resupply to occur until they were told to stop, so its the first reload that would be most time-consuming. If you had the new rounds ready and by the weapon, then 3 minutes makes sense. But if not, then 10-20 minutes is probably a better estimate, dropping back towards the 3 minute mark as time goes on. On the other hand, DC's were (erroneously) believed at the time to be far more effective than hedge-hog and as the same people who were resupplying HH's were also bringing up the DC's, it's entirely possible the HH was only used once whilst in asdic contact, with the reload occurring once contact was lost.
I'm simply asking of anyone knows, or can provide evidence for, the reload rates, the rest of it is surmise.