While I decided I disagreed with many of his assumptions (after actually analyzing the data on sinkings he presented), I found the thread interesting. I was honestly surprised at the way the data come out—German torpedoes not being much (if at all) better than the mk14 (reliability aside). I was sorry to see the thread closed.
He tended to attack personally at every opportunity, however. I think my disagreements were pretty even-handed. I'm fine with anyone modding, and I think that the best possible way is to be open about what you are doing and why. The community in general benefits from the open transfer of information, agree or disagree with the intent.
|