Have you tried adventure/quest type games ? What was your favorite ?
For me, in first place I still remember the week lasting effect after completing Fahrenheit aka Indigo Prophecy. Very immersive, calling in strong emotions!
In second place for me was: The Moment of Silence;
Then Syberia 1 and 2;
And many more which I can't remember now. Loved to play puzzle solving games, still always do
