EVGA is a mighty fine company. I'll bet they can help you out. Clayp, check to make sure that graphics card is fully seated and try it again. Sometimes removing it and reinstalling it (rock it end to end in its slot a little to move out any dirt that might be on one of the pins) will fix you up. Also make sure you have all the power connections (if any) on the graphics card hooked up.
On my ASUS motherboard I had some strangely labeled power plug-in on my motherboard. In order to use SLI I had to give that some power, but my Asian manual didn't make that clear. For almost a year I had weirdness until I stumbled across a well-hidden sentence while looking for something else.
Take care Clayp and don't be a stranger around here.
