View Single Post
Old 04-12-08, 12:05 AM   #10
Kpt. Lehmann
GWX Project Director
 
Kpt. Lehmann's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jul 2005
Location: The Republic of Texas
Posts: 7,004
Downloads: 124
Uploads: 0


Default

Further supporting notes from Pablo, posted at the Lair:

Regarding the question of U-boat ranges, here are some potentially useful comparisons between the real world and the world as it is modeled in Silent Hunter III:
  • The surface area of the earth
    Real life: ~510 million square kilometers (km^2).

    SH3: ~933 million km^2 (180° N-S x 360° E-W x 14400 km^2/deg^2)
  • Distance per degree of longitude at 5° N/S latitude (Penang/Jakarta)
    Real world: ~111 km

    SH3: 120 km
  • Distance per degree of longitude at 45° N/S latitude (La Spezia)
    Real world: ~79 km

    SH3 World: 120 km
  • Distance per degree of longitude at 63° N/S latitude (Trondheim)
    Real world: ~50 km

    SH3 World: 120 km
  • Distance per degree of longitude at 74° N/S latitude (Svalbard)
    Real world: ~31 km

    SH3 World: 120 km
  • Distance per degree of latitude (all latitudes)
    Real world: ~111 km

    SH3 World: 120 km
The complicating game factors are:
  • Almost all of the gameplay in SH3/GWX occurs between 74°N latitude (Svalbard) and about 40°S latitude (Cape Town, South Africa; Melbourne, Australia)
  • U-boat bases can be found from near the equator (Penang) to over 60 degrees N latitude (Trondheim).
  • Silent Hunter III entails a lot of east-west sailing as well as north-south, so I don't think we should base range changes solely on the effect of changing latitude.
I suggest basing the new range on the extent to which the SH3 world is larger than the real world at the point where the U-boats are operating, as follows:

SH3: the distance from Point "A" to Point "B" is always square root of (120^2 + 120^2), or about ~170km by the Pythagorean Theorem.

Real: distance obtained from "Latitude/Longitude Distance Calculator," http://www.nhc.noaa.gov/gccalc.shtml

Case 1: 45°N latitude (La Spezia)
Real life: the distance from Point "A" to Point "B" is ~136 km

The "SH3:Real" ratio is 170:136, or about 1.25:1
Case 2: 54°N latitude (Kiel)
Real life: the distance from Point "A" to Point "B" is ~128 km

The "SH3:Real" ratio is 170:128, or about 1.33:1.
Case 3: 63°N latitude (Trondheim)
Real life: the distance from Point "A" to Point "B" is ~122 km

The "SH3:Real" ratio is 170:122, or about 1.39:1
I suggest increasing the U-boat ranges from their historical values by different amounts to account for the "fat, flat, and square" world of Silent Hunter III:
  • Type II U-boats: increase by about 33% for specified range/speed combinations, since they operate only in the mid-latitudes of the North Sea or the Black Sea
  • Type VII, IX, and XXI U-boats: increase their range by about 25% at specified range/speed combinations, since they can or will operate from the poles to the equator, and the 25% increase roughly reflects the increased size of the world half-way between the poles and the equator.
__________________

www.thegreywolves.com
All you need is good men. - Heinrich Lehmann-Willenbrock
Kpt. Lehmann is offline   Reply With Quote