I finally got a chance to check these out. My observations:
Stabiz:
As usual, quality work. The subject matter of Midway was a good choice and one that turned the tide of the war. Camera work was excellent! Of course the music selection was appropriate and I have to say the last song, A Hero Comes Home brought a bit of a tear to my eye.

I like the comment/dedicated to all the Nutters at Subsim and UBI. You got us to a 'T' :rotfl:
Tex:
Brilliant start to your video. Showing all the forces headed to the land of the rising sun. Showing San Fran and New York gearing up and heading out. Absolutely brilliant. Of course the sound track chosen was great. The sound track was fantastic from the movie Pearl. I see you put a lot of thought into your work. Camera work was great!
Nisgeis:
What can I say bro? The subject matter was whatever the creater wanted. You created a video on the submarine and what it was about. Although yours was short and sweet, it was awesome! I loved the use of the game sounds with the game music! I really did. Your camera work was good. I have to say for your first try, awesome.
My vote goes to Nisgeis for a job well done and entering his creation knowing he was standing in the shadow of video giants.