I do not share melnibonian's concern bout the thread going ugly, BUT I share his belief that we should not start ANOTHER thread on this topic. There were a few such discussions and it would be much better just to continue one of the previous ones. It's not only a matter of keeping order on the Forum - I'm also almost sure that everything was allready said in that matter and it's no use to discuss it anew and anew. Wouldn't it be a bit boring?
A margin note: we, regular users, should try to keep some order on the Forums too, it's not only moderators job. The more threads on the same topic, the harder it's to find anything useful when you need it (by search).