I played Gun. Stinking pile of crap if you ask me. Always wanted to try Red Dead Revolver. Never got to.
I played Call of Juarez last year. It's a great game. Kinda sucks that it's so short though. I beat it in 2 days and had no reson to play again. Scripted, not much replayability.
However I never really got to try much multiplayer. From what I saw it seemed a little lacking. Has anybody gotten into CoJ mp? Are there a lot of people playing it? If the mp is good I might buy it. Otherwise I don't think it's worth it for such limited replayability.
The game has a really cool duel boss fight thing in some parts of the game. Am I the only one who thinks they were dumb for not making that duel part into a multiplayer game mode? That would be hella fun.
Sucks that the western genre is so underrepresented in video games. Guess it might be another year or 5 till the next good one.