[neeyik]

Originally Posted by Ark

I believe the final rating is the average of the 4 scores given, rounded up.

The final rating isn't an average of the others but a separate "overall" feeling of the game. Our scoring methodology is given here: http://www.yougamers.com/aboutus/methodology/

Originally Posted by Steeltrap

I believe the purpose of a review is to reflect correctly the experience the reviewer has when trying a game, both positive and negative. Explanations should be given where possible, and points of view clearly differentiated from statements of fact.

Totally agree and any time that we stray from this, then let me know!

I thought the review was the best and most reasonable I've yet read. I took the trouble to write something on your site to that effect.

Thanks for doing so - I'm sure Aaron will be very gratified to read all these comments, given the time he took testing it (I also did a reasonable amount of testing too).

Originally Posted by gg5506

sh4 after practice sh4 is easier than sh3 to play.

I've played SH3 for so long though that I struggle quite a lot with #4 - especially plotting courses, marking lines and so on. It seemed a much quicker and easier thing to do before than selecting a pencil image dumped amongst a pile of other tools.