Yep - that seems a little excessive. I did some more tests though on the Large tanker that I was experimenting with, and it seems to hae a weak point directly aft of the forward superstructure. Pop a single torp in him at this exact spot and he will break in 2. Kind of a tricky shot though. Seemed easier to hit specific points in SH3. The TDC in SHIV will plug a torp directly into the middle of a target. Had to use the spread option to aim slightly left.
Using 100% realism by the way.
-S
__________________
 
|