One thing not mentioned yet. The difference between the ASW capabilities of thier respective enemies. I suspect the Gato's would have had a tougher time if Japanese ASW was as good as Allied. Thoughts?
And of course the Fleet submarine wasn't used in the way it was envisioned at the time of its design...
i do agree that its apples and oranges but that doesn't make this discussion any less interesting, and it does make me think more about all these wonderful boats!
Cheers,
|