[razark]

There's one thing, and one thing only, that puts SH4 at the top of the list.
Graphics.


If you want you sim to look good, there's absolutely no other choice. It is far above the next possible choice.


However, if you want gameplay, features, and so on, SH4 does come in second. There is a lot of stuff that should have been included in SH4 that was left out. SH1 covers these so much better, but just doesn't look as good.




There's also a few other entries in the series, but they lack the essential parts that a truly successful submarine simulation needs, submarines. All they have is u-boats.