If you want gritty realism, NYGM with all of the h.sie and Stiebler options is a good way to go.
Just don't plan on seeing lots of traffic in comparison to LSH (or even GWX).
Great thing about SH3 and SH4 is there are tons of mods for any player.
CCoM, NYGM, GWX, WAC, LSH for SH3.
TMO, RFB, FOTRSU, Dark Waters, We Dive at Dawn, Soviet Waterways for SH4.
|