SUBSIM Radio Room Forums - View Single Post

Skybird · 05-09-06, 03:11 PM

The questions were so simple, and still no answer why Muslims in that place do not engage in effective action to prevent what is going on IN THE NAME OF ISLAM. Who is interested in some minor local demonstration (that does not compare innsize to the uproar cuased by the Danish cartoons anyway) in other countires about an event in Belgium? O asked why the people there do not do anything. Why they do not get demkanded by global Ummah to do something. Ummah is all one great happy family, isn't it

I tell you a simple explanation, Konovalov: your perception of what Islam is, is too reasonable, too Westernized. You use tools that are too advanced for a too primitive problem. 21st century meets medieval. Both does not match, both are not on the same level. A categorial error of first order, Kant maybe would call it (I always mess up his categorial errors...). That's why you don't get beyond the discrepancy between what you see Islam like, and what Islam sees itself like, and you even do not realize that discrepancy, thus labelling your view of Islam the self-understanding of Islam in general. And this is why you cannot answer that simple question. You maybe are beyond Islam - and even do not realize it, like a child that has learned to swim, but does not know, and thus does not dare to let go the grip in the wall of the swimming pool.

You are too good for Islam

That's how I think about you. But that way you nevertheless can do damage without even realizing it, and help spreading a thing that is bad, and do so with only the best intentions.

I leave here, there is nothing more to say. There is a possebility that in the future some events will influence you in that way that you suddenly realize all this, and then this confusion maybe will no longer bind you. But neither can nor will I help in that. It's your life, not mine.

No hard feelings, good luck!

Skybird

05-09-06, 03:11 PM	#25
Skybird Soaring Join Date: Sep 2001 Location: the mental asylum named Germany Posts: 42,637 Downloads: 10 Uploads: 0	The questions were so simple, and still no answer why Muslims in that place do not engage in effective action to prevent what is going on IN THE NAME OF ISLAM. Who is interested in some minor local demonstration (that does not compare innsize to the uproar cuased by the Danish cartoons anyway) in other countires about an event in Belgium? O asked why the people there do not do anything. Why they do not get demkanded by global Ummah to do something. Ummah is all one great happy family, isn't it I tell you a simple explanation, Konovalov: your perception of what Islam is, is too reasonable, too Westernized. You use tools that are too advanced for a too primitive problem. 21st century meets medieval. Both does not match, both are not on the same level. A categorial error of first order, Kant maybe would call it (I always mess up his categorial errors...). That's why you don't get beyond the discrepancy between what you see Islam like, and what Islam sees itself like, and you even do not realize that discrepancy, thus labelling your view of Islam the self-understanding of Islam in general. And this is why you cannot answer that simple question. You maybe are beyond Islam - and even do not realize it, like a child that has learned to swim, but does not know, and thus does not dare to let go the grip in the wall of the swimming pool. You are too good for Islam That's how I think about you. But that way you nevertheless can do damage without even realizing it, and help spreading a thing that is bad, and do so with only the best intentions. I leave here, there is nothing more to say. There is a possebility that in the future some events will influence you in that way that you suddenly realize all this, and then this confusion maybe will no longer bind you. But neither can nor will I help in that. It's your life, not mine. No hard feelings, good luck! Skybird __________________ If you feel nuts, consult an expert.