View Single Post
Old 10-31-16, 06:42 PM   #5
jadervason
Bosun
 
Join Date: Aug 2009
Posts: 69
Downloads: 15
Uploads: 0
Default

When it comes to max no-escape range/min safe distance I prefer a little dirtier of a method.

Torpedo gain rate * torpedo run time. Let's take my favorite example first...

Torpedo gain rate: 55 knot Mk48 adcap gaining on a 43 knot Alfa is 12 knot gain rate.

Torpedo run time: 55 knot Mk 48 can go 23(?) nautical miles = 25 minute run time. ((23nm/55knots)=.4 hours*60minutes=25minutes)) (For figuring safe distance also consider the # of minutes it will take you to put the torpedo directly behind you and reach top speed.)

Gaining at 12 knots for 25 minutes = 405 yards/minute * 25 minutes = 10125 yards max no-escape range on an Alfa.

Now assuming for some reason the target is a Sturgeon or Ohio or Rubis(?) with 25 knot top speed.

Torpedo gain rate: 55 knot Mk48 adcap gaining on a 25 knot sub is 30 knot gain rate.

Gaining at 30 knots for 25 minutes = 1012(!) yards/minute * 25 minutes = 25300 yard max no-escape range on a 25 knot boat.

Ok but what about the poor Alfa skipper?

40 knot TEST-71 can go 15km/8.1 nautical miles for a run time of 12.2 minutes.

40 knot TEST-71 - 33 knot 688 = 7 knot gain rate

7 knot gain rate * 12.2 minutes = 236 yards/minute * 12 minutes = 2879 yard no-escape zone. Poor Alfa skipper

So the finally tally.

Mk48 no-escape range against Alfa = 10125yards
Mk48 no-escape range against 25 knot boat = 25300 yards
TEST-71 no escape range against 33 knot boat = 2879 yards

Did I overlook anything? Let me know
jadervason is offline   Reply With Quote