Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Salvadoreno
Hey Beery while i really did love your RUb 1.45, i find it offensive to the NYGM and GW modders when u say RUb 1.45 is more realistic and such to these other obviously superior mods.
|
When accusing me of saying something, please do me the courtesy of quoting the specific sentence you take issue with and its context. Otherwise it looks like trolling (especially since the bit you did quote has nothing at all to do with your argument). I've explained the reasons for my opinions on both NYGM and GW, and whatever your opinion might be, I won't apologise for having my own opinion.
For those folks who haven't read the post he's referring to, I'll clarify:
I said that NYGM was less realistic than RUb only because it carries a mod which is unfinished (the Milk Cow mod) and which causes significant realism problems. True, you don't 'have' to use it, but it's there nonetheless, and some people may be led to believe that it is realistic to have what amounts to a dry dock in mid-ocean. I also said that in ALL other respects, NYGM was probably SUPERIOR to, and MORE realistic than, RUb.
As for the GW mod, I said that GW was less realistic because I'm led to understand that the GW mod is supposed to give players a balance between realism and playability - this is how it's marketed. As such it can't possibly be as realistic as RUb or NYGM. Realism isn't its primary focus. As for it being inferior, the person who started that specific thread was asking for 'the most realistic' mod. In that context, GW is inferior to RUb and NYGM. If the context related to playability, GW might indeed be superior, but that wasn't the context of that thread.