Hello Pdiddy,
The only way I can answer is to compare your question with when someone asks me which is the best single malt.
You have to taste them all to appreciate their differences, and to find one you really like, as they are all good.
Just like SH1, 2, 3, 4 & 5 are all good to their respective devotees.
To me SH3 is like a good glass of Laphroaig, once tasted never put down.
It is really a matter of choice and taste.
Give it a go with both SH3 and the Laphroaig
