Micky, you better call for killing all mankind preemptively. Then you will be saved.
I reject your mental experiments here. I refer to the words and "evidences" and "facts" your CIC said he had in hand. What you do now is just an attempt to distract from that. As often before.
A reason given before a war is a reason. A reason given after a war is a foul excuse. the reasons beeing given before were fakes. the reason you give now are foul excuses.