Thread: Dud Torps
View Single Post
Old 02-17-14, 06:28 AM   #54
HertogJan
Weps
 
Join Date: Dec 2012
Posts: 357
Downloads: 137
Uploads: 0
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by anotherdemon View Post
I've never trusted the fast option. I reckon its messes up the impact pistol and makes it misfire*.

It also means you sometimes can't get too close or you'll dud out due to the torp running too fast; a nice and slow approach takes a longer course to the target, hence it has a longer time to enable.
True, but with slow settings vessels could evaide the torpedoes more easily, depending on distance, weather and sea conditions obviously.


Quote:
Originally Posted by anotherdemon View Post
(I also only trust mag. when in absolutely flat seas or harbor raids, and even then, I'll only use them if I have to shoot down the throat or up the the other end.)

*You know how those feelings go. If you get more duds with one setting, and less with another, you'll go with the latter

O, and I use mag. on DDs, of course, but I try not to tackle with them.
I use magnetic sometimes but rarely, as for DD's, I have MK10's setup in aft torpedo room just for them .

I only got to early '43 once so I can't comment on dud percentages after that and never tried cuties or any other torpedoes.
HertogJan is offline   Reply With Quote