Well if you want total and complete realistic gameplay, I would say go for SH3+GWX3 for starters. SH5 is all about the eye candy and keeping drama under control within the sub.
Here's my "mod soup" to give you an idea.
GWX Optional Mods (comes with the full mod)
GWX-16km atmosphere
GWX-Alternate loadscreen full circle
GWX-Alternative Flotillas
GWX-Axis Mediterranean aircraft skins
GWX-Enhanced Damage Effects
GWX-No Medals on Crew
GWX-VIIC41 Player sub
GWX-Late War Sensors and Snorkel Antennas
"Ala Carte" mods from Subsim.
Recognition Manual Data
Depth Charge Water disturbance by TheDarkWraith
"No Jawohl" mod by Sailor Steve
Das Boot Periscope Sounds
Destroyers and Corvettes realistic sounds
Hitman's optics for GWX3v.1 (A must have!)
Enhanced Torpedo Damage Graphics v2.0
WB's Fuel Economy v1.2
WB's Mission Orders Lite v1.1
Extra Historical Bases
Ultimate Aircraft Sound Mod
WB's Renown Replacement
Lifeboats and Debris v4
Coming from a guy who's played and owns Silent Hunter 3,4, and 5, I would say SH3 is the best hands down with the right mod soup. No other title in the SH series has had this much attention from modders and people fixing bugs.
|