It's a moot point. Yellowstone could pop at any time within the next 500 years and that puppy will likely wipe out most of the human race. The only survivors will be those lucky enough to hole up in one of those government bunkers.The pyroclastic cloud will bulldoze the surface of everything at 700 MPH and blot out the sun for years.
Evolution will begin all over again.

Eventually, another Wolferz and another Armistead will develop and have the same old arguments.