Quote:
Originally Posted by sublynx
I can't agree with the cowardly bit in the sense that a U-boatman's life was extremely risky. One could argue that U-boats hit defenseless or helpless targets. That's warfare. Basically all of warfare tries to hit the enemy from a safe position. That's why armor and shields and longrange weapons like a bow or a sniper rifle were developed. Strategy and tactics in all warfare strives to achieve a position where you can kill the enemy in perfect safety.
Heroic? My grandfather told me that when he went to the front in the winter of 1941/1942 the first task he faced was to pile frozen enemy carcasses to make a temporary winter road more durable. It was easier than felling trees as there had been an encirclement and the enemy had been pushed to a small area and then killed in piles. Probably those soldiers killed had very little ammunition or food when they were killed and they were probably killed mostly by artillery and mortar fire from a safe distance.
Heroism and war is a very difficult thing to define. I think it's easier to think of war as a basically insane slaughter that a society should avoid if at all possible. I don't play SH3 to feel brave or heroic. I like history, geometry and challenge and would probably desert at the first chance if I was to participate in real submarine warfare.
Interesting points of view anyways, guntherprien. I hope other people decide to share their views on this  |
Thanks Sublynx,your reply was the kind of response I was looking for.
I love sh3 with GWX3 but after reading many,many books on the subject,am left with a sour taste in my mouth.
I keep thinking about a passage in Buccheims' 'Das Boot' where the captain can't reconcile himself to sinking seaworthy vessels,himself being a sailor on a sailing ship.
The point I was trying to make was that it must be difficult to commit fellow sailors,regardless of nationality to a watery death,especially if one is a submarine commander.
I have been a member of this forum for many years and in no way wish to denigrate it,I just wish to share my feelings.
In real life,I don't think I could sink a real unarmed merchantman with all the subsequent loss of life.
Long live SH3 GWX though.
May your God go with you.