View Single Post
Old 11-13-11, 06:19 PM   #2
Randomizer
Stowaway
 
Posts: n/a
Downloads:
Uploads:
Default

As stated, I believe your initial premise is invalid and the data you seek so subjective as to be useless but if you can get a consensus for your arbitrary "sneakyness" scores, more power too you.

An example of how the inherent variables make scoring useless is in one of my active careers I have had U-19 shadowing a Soviet convoy in the Black Sea in broad daylight and was never detected by the escorting destroyer. Since it's within visual range and I do not use the 16km atmosphere mod, I remained unseen as I attempted to get into an attack position. Eventually worsening weather and the onset of night ended the pursuit but for several hours I operated within visual range of merchants and a destroyer without being sighted. So, in my experiance, your blanket statement:
Quote:
My general comment for GWX would be that daylight stealth factor is too low (Ds spot you at over 20 km)...
is manifestly inaccurate.

Also having your boat operating at 3 knots and 90 degrees to a target cannot be considered an approach unless the target is for all intents and purposes stopped.

It is well known that use of TC in the SH3-4 series greatly increases your vulnerability to detection so unless testing is conducted in real time any scores will likely be skewed accordingly.

Anyway, good luck getting the scores you want.
  Reply With Quote