I'd spring for a new Hard drive.

If you live in USA try TigerDirect or NewEgg to see what you like, cost, Specs and reviews and warrenty info.
Then go to Amazon via SubSim and get best price and maybe Free Shipping.

..
With that very nice Mobo and all the other new hardware it, deserves a Sata hard drive. Holy Jebuzz !!! Don't cut corners now especially when their all on sale.