Oneshot, I've actually found that a torpedo that initially circles in the opposite direction of the target can be just as effective as one that circles directly towards the target, since its approach angle once it completes its circle is often better for preventing spoofing from decoys.
I've dropped many torpedos with show truth on, and the difference in weapon effectiveness actually isn't terribly different.
But I agree, there should be some predictability. I'm not trying to suggest that I dissagree with you and Beer about that basic point.
__________________
LW

|