You talk about Rub HT, IC, and SH commander?
I don't think it matters what order you put these in. They don't use the same files as far as I know. Then I have not seen the latest SH 3 Commander.
You also asked about the bad points in IC.
I guess it depends on what you like and not.
Before Jason put the convoy tighter it was a hughe distance from escorts and convoy ships. That gave the possibility to hunt without interference from escorts if you just could make it into the convoy and kept your self silent and invisible. Now this is fixed so this manouver is harder to perform.
If you like realism in convoy's, then this is the mod.
I know Wolfmann has also made a very good convoy mod. He has put his effort in correct escorts. Then there is more singleships added. (if I remember correct) Tried it and it was quite nice!
Just a mater of taste I guess!
__________________
 
|