Quote:
|
No it's not. That is the traditional view. It then cites individuals who differ. Not major sectarian branches.
|
Can you run through the numerous major sectarian branches and then place the 4 from the piece?
Quote:
|
Throughout the entire article it says the same. The traditional view is that death is it for men, but this guy, or that guy disagrees.
|
No it says that there is disageement and there is nothing in the koran itself to support the view given by the 4.
Quote:
|
It then breaks down the thoughts of the others---who as it said right above, are outside the mainstream of thought on the issue.
|
just 4 views out of many many schools do not equal "mainstream".
Quote:
|
Would you now accept that your statement is incorrect?
|
Don't be silly. It is his long held view and he is always right as he is an expert
though isn't it funny that he always says there is only one version and one interpretation yet now says you have a different version, plus of course as he says the writing of the texts becomes increasingly vague and careless as it progresses where does that leave his claim about the clear meaning and only interpretation of the text?
What is the betting there will follow a wall of text which is a cut and paste of a wall of text insisting that he is an expert on your religion so you are wrong as he read a book and you havn't read a book ?
