Good points. I'm a bit put off by the thought of some of those things as well. I don't recall which thread it was, but someone needed to sink five warships and a carrier to complete a mission objective. WTH?
Just how many torpedoes and advanced stealth technology was equipped on that U-boat?
I did vote yes, as if it matters. But coming from the older SH3 school of submarine warfare I'm starting to doubt that decision. Then again I don't know the power of the campaign editor (is there one in SH5?) and how much of the scripting can be changed. I'll still have to watch and think on it.