View Single Post
Old 06-27-10, 07:51 AM   #15
Tribesman
Stowaway
 
Posts: n/a
Downloads:
Uploads:
Default

Quote:
His claims mostly are wrong, why they are wrong has been explained several times (on Sharia, for example),
Says the man who claimed there is only one sharia
Funny really he claims there is only one muslim too, the nutcase kind.
Quote:
but to silence them by ridiculing them or distorting them, or linking them to racism.
Hey its Sky who says he can't join protests without involved neo-nazis and cannot make his own protests without the Neio-Nazis coming along with a big "me too".
If by your own admission you walk with racist scum and have the same message as racist scum then it does say something about linking to racism.


Quote:
I am sorry if I haven't been clear enough. The dogma mentioned by the author was not explained, probably one of the gravest mistakes in both books, as they speak of Islam without explaining what they are thinking about. You are right in saying that there are different interpretations, yet the dogma remains and the corpus of the texts remain the same.
I understand what you are saying, yet there are many ways to read and interpret the same texts.
So the dogma are the principles ain't they, based on the text...well apart from the last one as that came about due to the first major split was over the principles and it is still split on what the sixth principle meant.
So since the even dogma which is the core are a matter of disputed interpretations where does that leave the arguement that the dogma remains the same?


Quote:
Since I am not a Muslim scholar and the literature I have read makes no mention of this, I must apologise and leave the answer to your question to someone else.
OK a simpler question. What is a fatwa?

Quote:
You cannot deny the fact the Sharia courts exist in the UK and they there are not ruling in favour the of women
I certainly can, as that would be discriminatory and against the law. sharia in Britain is set up exactly as it has been set up for well over 100 years.

Quote:
Concerning other groups, I agree, they shouldn't have privileges based on religion or culture,
So now you agree that it isn't "only muslims" that get it.
But why shouldn't they?


Quote:
What is funny is that you have proven you have zero knowledge whatsoever about the Balkans with that statement.
Really?
Quote:
I'm a Slovenian
Wow.

Quote:
Our war didn't include Muslims, as it ended in 10 days
Your war??????
Quote:
So, no civil war where I come from
Hold on you just said you had your war???????
Quote:
Slovenia was newer truly a part of the Balkans
Who mentioned the Balkans???????

Slovenia was part of Yugoslavia yes?
Yusoslavia was a pile of states that seperated in a set of civil wars yes?
Sooooooo........
Quote:
when you lot had your nice set of civil wars
Your little cvil war that you didn't have even though it happened was one of a set of civil wars that split apart the constituent parts of Yugoslavia......Yes
  Reply With Quote