Perfect subsim game:
- simulation of submarine (SH series)
- simulation of destroyer (EnigmaRT, DC)
- simulation of other heavy warship (DC)
- control each weapon separately (SH, EnigmaRT, DC, BS series)
- control few units together (DC, BS series)
- additional control of planes/merchants (BS series)
- easy interface (SH3, DC)
- easy gun control (BS series)
- mission editor (SH seires)
- modability (SH series)
- amazing multiplayer battles as SUBvsDD or NAVYvsNAVY (DC, BS series)
And the winner is: SH2/DC
FAIL: poor graphic
FAIL: poor stability
FAIL: stupid AI
FAIL: no merchant/planes control
SPECIAL BONUS: possible playing as Yamato, Bismarck, Iowa, KGV
II place: SH4 ADV mode
FAIL: only one player for all naval units
FAIL: not stable UBI servers
FAIL: only 4 players per game
FAIL: no torpedo warfare against enemy submarines
FAIL: no epic battles between enemy fleets
SPECIAL BONUS: combat human vs human in classic SH game
III-place: BATTLESTATIONS series
FAIL: no simulation game
FAIL: no mission editor
FAIL: too many planes (naval game?)
FAIL: very hard game as submarine against humans
FAIL: human must control group of units, no selected ships with AI support
SPECIAL BONUS: direct control of planes and merchants (merchants only in modded missions)
__________________
|