There are dozens if not hundreds of player reviews here.
the only thing "official" we have so far received from Subsim.com on the matter has been a "Preview"
sort of like a pre-release review.
it can be found on the main page here
http://www.subsim.com/2010_02/sh5/pr...h5_feb2010.php
the reality of the situation is...
SH5 is a decent subsim, especially once patched and modded.
but it is the experience of 99% of the fan base... that the game is UNPLAYABLE better than half the time with this DRM OSP issue of server connectivity problems