Quote:
|
I would be way more willing to believe in what you say if you were finally telling people where you get your info from.
|
Info comes from many places
Quote:
|
If everything Skybird says is made up or untrue then show us the counter evidence!
|
Where have I said that? I have only said tha Skybird makes things up to fit his arguement , I have not said that everything he says is made up.
If you paid attention you might notice I specicificly ask skybird to back up his claims ...as in those c;aims that are obviously false , the most common of which lately is easily demonstrated by the simple question "what law?".
On no occasion has Skybird attempted to try and justify the falsehoods he has written, instead we get.... i went to muslim countries ....i read books...you are ignorant.
Quote:
|
one might agree or disagree with his sources but at least he tells us where it is from
|
Actually no he doesn't, in the main he sticks to non contentious issues for which you can provide a whole library of sources, but the non contentious issues do not make point.
When he wants to make a point he invariablty heads towards a very small number of sources. The most common of which takes specific points from a very respected, very well established scholar who is reknowned world wide.
Every time that scholars works are used to "prove" a specific bit of scriptue means "A".
Just about every time the scholars work really shows that the scripture cannot possibly mean "A" but it is omitted.
The fact that the "proof" version is so widely accepted and circulated does not give it credibility .
However the fact that the Jewish scholar of Islam rejects the misuse and misrepresentation of his studies and takes legal actions against the crazy racist hate sites that claim to use his work...well that speaks volumes doesn't it.
So schroeder, Skybird does write some good stuff on Islam but really lets himself down badly, I however could be far more critical on many aspects of Islam(after all there are sommany things to get your teeth into).
But. That should be a big ...
But
I would not have to make up ****e to make my point like Skybird does.
If you are in doubt then do a simple search for skybirds "claims", match them to the "claims" on Jihadwatch.
Then take the step to the Jihadwatch scholarly source
Then you can see why that source is really ********d offwith Jihadwatch and its misrepresentation of his studies.