[Sonarman]

I'm not too bothered about the graphics and certainly think SH4 water looked good, where it fell down and where most attention I think should be paid is to the ship physics, how the ship performs and pitches and rolls with the waves etc. This was portrayed quite well in SH3 but was pretty much diabolical in SH4 where the whole "on rails" feeling detracted massively from the atmosphere of the game, this is a definite "must fix" for SH5.