im torn on this issue, on one hand i agree it would be imersive and add another element to the game but on the other i see it as something the captain wouldnt be doing like loading torpedos, it would be nice to see the crew do it just like we will be able to see the crew loading torpedos in front of you but it has nothing to do with what you as the captain would have taken part in while running the boat.
in RL you would just get the decoded messages and thats it so i could see it as a possible damage result or routine mechanical failure thing "sir the enigma is broken, we can no longer send or recieve messages" but not as a routine of coding and decoding your own messages i dont see it as realism but unrealism for a captain to take part in.
but again i think it would be great to decode messages at first and then it gets old real fast if you "have to" do it.
|