[Knipper]

Without wishing to sound patronizing, it's SH3 for me, mainly because the various GWX's have bought turned it into a thoroughly amazing experience. Also, I guess being English, I identify with the Battle of the Atlantic far more readily than with that of the Pacific. Coincidentally (it being the anniversary of the start of WWII) today I bought SH4 and, having played it all afternoon, I've have decided to donate it to a local charity shop (probably NOT the British Legion). Of course, SH5 could be another matter. We shall see...