View Single Post
Old 08-07-09, 04:10 PM   #10
Aramike
Ocean Warrior

Best of SUBSIM
Chairman
 
Join Date: Dec 2008
Location: Milwaukee, WI
Posts: 3,207
Downloads: 59
Uploads: 0
Default

Quote:
And its pretty tacky to dismiss all those who died because of political expediency which you are showing here.
Excuse me? How am I showing "political expediency"? I'm making the obvious point that the terms we use are irrelevent. Rather, the behaviors are what matters.

Ever hear the phrase, "a rose by any other name would smell just as sweet."?

I don't really give a damn if we call it a war, a police action, or whatever - as long as we are taking the steps necessary to prevent such a tragedy.

But nothing is tackier than someone (you) posting a tragic photo of an individual's final moment simply because you want YOUR term of choice used. That photo has absolutely NO bearing upon the intellectual argument of which term is correct.

Frankly, you were attempting the cheap tactic of soliciting a knee-jerk reaction to justify your point. It was transparent and it has failed.
Quote:
Guess what, this happened and to ignore it or criticize those who post pictures of it demean those killed and their families.
Are you out of your mind? Who's ignoring what happened on 9/11? The only thing "demeaning" to such families is your insistance upon using them as fodder to feed your argument on semantics.

Is it impossible for you to frame your discussions within the realm of reality?
Quote:
It happened, innocent people died because it was a law enforcement action and this is one picture. It is easy to forget or pass it off because you haven't seen it recently. As DiNero said..........This is this.
Umm, flat out wrong. 9/11 was in no way a result of it falling under the purview of law enforcement. It happened because the scope of responsibilities within law enforcement were poorly-defined.

You're attempting to make an argument through the silly notion that "law enforcement" is an end upon itself, and therefore cannot make the adjustments necessary to combat something that was once beyond its purview.

I have no problem with counter-terrorism being called a War on Terror or being called a police-action of some kind. So long as the bombs keep falling in the right place and the US stays safe, "a rose by any other name..."
Aramike is offline   Reply With Quote