SUBSIM Radio Room Forums - View Single Post

Nisgeis · 03-24-09, 05:58 PM

That clip is heavily editted and the clips do not seem to be from the same sub. For example, at the start, they are manning a 4/50" bow deck gun and the next shot they are firing a 5/25" stern mounted deck gun. The shot of the sub firing at the sinking ship, doesn't look like a standard fleet boat sub, it looks like it's been modified and if anything it looks like it's firing rockets at the target. There's no actual shot of a guy shooting and then a pan to the victim in the water. The people shooting out to sea with rifles are generally shooting far too high to be shooting at the people depicted floating in the water.

The one shot that does look like it could have been a shooting is the one where the guy has a grenade he's trying to throw. That particular clip looks like it's been shot from a destroyer, as the equipment and structure don't match a fleet boat and nor does the decking.

Just a few edits and the next YouTube sensation: US Sub kills Bambi.

03-24-09, 05:58 PM	#8
Nisgeis Ocean Warrior Join Date: Jan 2008 Posts: 2,909 Downloads: 77 Uploads: 11	That clip is heavily editted and the clips do not seem to be from the same sub. For example, at the start, they are manning a 4/50" bow deck gun and the next shot they are firing a 5/25" stern mounted deck gun. The shot of the sub firing at the sinking ship, doesn't look like a standard fleet boat sub, it looks like it's been modified and if anything it looks like it's firing rockets at the target. There's no actual shot of a guy shooting and then a pan to the victim in the water. The people shooting out to sea with rifles are generally shooting far too high to be shooting at the people depicted floating in the water. The one shot that does look like it could have been a shooting is the one where the guy has a grenade he's trying to throw. That particular clip looks like it's been shot from a destroyer, as the equipment and structure don't match a fleet boat and nor does the decking. Just a few edits and the next YouTube sensation: US Sub kills Bambi. __________________ -------------------------------- This space left intentionally blank.