Dont remember what I voted (prolly FEAR), but now I got to change it to FEAR 2. That gotta be one of the most scariest games I've played, the scary bits are done very well. Like in one spot, you're in a biggish room with a large round pool in it. The lights go out and your flashlight starts to flicker, as you scan the room, at some point the little girl's (Alma) head is visible just for a 0.5 seconds on the bottom part of your flashlight's cone, standing just 1m away from you. That scared the fark out of me.
Tho, having watched some youtube clips from ppl playing the same scene, you dont necessarely see Alma if you are pointing the light the wrong way, seems I got lucky when I caught her.